Abigail's Fate: Deaths, Endings & Theories Explored!

Mrs. Michaela Deckow IV 07 May 2025

Ever wondered about the fates of characters named Abigail across various fictional universes? The recurring theme of death, survival, and complex relationships seems to follow many of these Abigails, making their stories all the more compelling. From battling vampires to grappling with the darkness of their pasts, the journeys of these characters are often fraught with peril and intrigue.

Let's delve into the narratives surrounding several prominent "Abigails" in film, television, and video games. The 2024 film Abigail, starring Melissa Barrera and Dan Stevens, offers a visceral vampire tale. The climax sees Abigail and Joey (Barrera) joining forces to overcome Frank, who has been transformed into a vampire himself by Lambert in an attempt to eliminate Abigail, the titular vampire. The film culminates with Joey and Frank as the remaining figures.

Attribute	Details
Character Name	Abigail
Film	Abigail (2024)
Portrayed By	Alisha Weir
Key Relationships	Joey (Melissa Barrera), Frank (potentially), Lambert
Character Arc	A kidnapped young girl who is actually a centuries-old vampire.
Synopsis	A group of criminals kidnap a ballerina, only to discover she is a powerful vampire.
Genre	Horror, Thriller
Themes	Vampirism, Survival, Betrayal
Reference	IMDb - Abigail (2024)

In the world of Red Dead Redemption, Abigail Marston's fate is equally poignant. In the epilogue of Red Dead Redemption 1, Abigail passes away, though the specific cause of her death is never explicitly stated. Theories abound, with some suggesting that a broken heart, stemming from the death of her husband, John Marston, contributed to her demise. After Johns confrontation with his enemies, which leaves him dead, Abigail and Jack return to the ranch, only to find a tragic end awaits Abigail as well.

Switching gears to the television series Hannibal, the character of Abigail Hobbs presents a dark and twisted narrative. Abigail is the daughter and accomplice of serial killer Garrett Jacob Hobbs. Her character is portrayed as a skilled hunter with a knack for manipulation, mirroring traits seen in Hannibal Lecter himself. Abigail looks up to Hannibal, partly out of gratitude for saving her life, but also because of the treatment she receives from him. While some sources online might suggest uncertainty about her fate, Abigail is revealed to have died from her injuries in the "Primavera" episode. Despite her death, Will Graham frequently hallucinates her presence.

Attribute	Details
Character Name	Abigail Hobbs
Series	Hannibal
Portrayed By	Kacey Rohl
Key Relationships	Garrett Jacob Hobbs (father), Hannibal Lecter (surrogate father figure), Will Graham
Character Arc	A young woman grappling with the horrific actions of her father, manipulated by Hannibal Lecter.
Synopsis	A psychological thriller series exploring the relationship between FBI investigator Will Graham and forensic psychiatrist Hannibal Lecter, who is secretly a cannibalistic serial killer.
Genre	Crime, Drama, Horror, Thriller
Themes	Manipulation, Trauma, Identity, Morality
Reference	IMDb - Hannibal

The name "Abigail" also appears in The Crucible, Arthur Miller's play about the Salem witch trials. Throughout the hysteria depicted in the play, Abigail Williamss motivations are portrayed as driven by jealousy and a desire for revenge against Elizabeth Proctor. Her actions ignite the flames of paranoia and ultimately contribute to the tragic events of the trials.

In The Haunting of Hill House, another Abigail meets a tragic end. Abigail Dudley is a character whose presence is shrouded in mystery. For a time, it is implied that she is a ghost, with characters referring to her as Luke's imaginary friend. This adds to the eerie and unsettling atmosphere of the series.

Attribute	Details
Character Name	Abigail Dudley
Series	The Haunting of Hill House
Portrayed By
Key Relationships	Luke Crain (Implied imaginary friend)
Character Arc	Mystery shrouded in ghost and implied friend
Synopsis	A thriller series exploring the haunted Hill house.
Genre	Horror, Drama
Themes	Family, Trauma, Mystery
Reference	IMDb - The Haunting of Hill House

Shifting to a different genre, Abigail Tierney appears as a guest character on The Rookie. Played by Madeleine Coghlan, Abigail is Henry Nolan's fiance. Their story begins in college, and they eventually visit John Nolan to announce their engagement. Abigail also expresses interest in joining the LAPD.

In a different narrative, Abigail is depicted as an ordinary child adopted by Nathan and Layla. She was found abandoned in the streets and taken in by Layla, who had always desired a daughter but was unable to have more children. They keep Abigail hidden from the world, maintaining her existence as a secret. Kai Azer is sent to Abigail's home by the king, setting the stage for a potentially fantastical or adventurous storyline.

The question of Abigail's survival also arises in the context of "The Healer." Despite some online sources suggesting her death, Abigail does not die in this narrative. She experiences a miraculous remission. The story explores the concept of healers and the role of faith, suggesting that the ability to heal is deeply connected to one's belief.

Then, there's the Abigail known as Vanessa and Scarlet's mother. In "Began Again," she is seen sharpening a machete while Jess blows up red helium balloons with a map attached, indicating a search or mission. Abigail was at the farm while pregnant with Vanessa and Scarlett and remained there for the first few years of their lives. The narrative hints at Bruce Harrison's intention to experiment on the twins, suggesting a dark and potentially dangerous future for them.

In the recent movie Abigail, the character's ending is particularly noteworthy. Abigail displays her newfound affection for Joey, stemming from Joey's early attempts to protect her. The climax involves Abigail revealing that only experienced vampires who have lived for thousands of years can perform certain feats. Ultimately, she and Joey team up to defeat Frank in a gory and cathartic scene, staking him to death.

In one intense scene, Abigail appears suddenly, declaring that their game of cat and mouse is over. She launches an attack on Frank, who retaliates by biting her neck. However, she remains alive. Later, Joey, now conscious, tries to return to the library but finds the door locked. Abigail reappears, explaining that the only way to truly kill a vampire is to completely drain them of blood. Frank manages to overpower her before turning his attention back to Joey. He bites Joey on the neck and forces her to hold a stake, ordering her to kill Abigail. However, the tables turn as Abigail and Joey work together to eliminate Frank.

Another scene depicts Abigail's quick thinking and comedic timing. She kills Rickles almost immediately after he and Joey separate, showcasing her sharp wit and resourcefulness. In another instance, she uses Peter's crucifix necklace to stab him repeatedly, inflicting numerous small cuts. This highlights her determination and willingness to use any means necessary to survive.

Across these diverse narratives, the name "Abigail" is associated with characters facing extraordinary circumstances. Whether battling supernatural forces, confronting personal demons, or navigating complex relationships, these Abigails leave a lasting impression on their respective stories. The common threads of resilience, determination, and the struggle for survival make their journeys all the more captivating.

Whether it is Abigail Marston in Red dead redemption or Abigail Hobbs, daughter of serial killer these abigails are known for their survival and the way they change the course of their respective stories, either with wit or with their strength

The theme of death surrounds most of the Abigail but they are not simple as they seem, they show some sort of power to survive.